(First published September 17, 2014 on http://rothbardinstitutet.se in Swedish)
This article will give you a thorough introduction to what Bitcoin is, how it was created, how it works, what gives it value, and how it differs from regular national currencies, especially in the context of Keynesian and Austrian economic theory. In the end is also a brief account of what the technology behind Bitcoin can be used for in addition to the application as money.
The convention is to use uppercase letter (Bitcoin) when talking about the payment network, software and community, and to use lowercase letter (bitcoin) when talking about units of the currency. Unlike other currencies, Bitcoin is both a payment network and a currency simultaneously. This makes it fundamentally different from regular currencies such as the US dollar where the currency and payment networks are separate parts.
A simple analogy
To understand the significance of this it can be helpful to make an analogy. Imagine Bitcoin as a car that is simultaneously the road it is traveling on. This car can travel anywhere in the world and there are no border guards or third parties who can stop it or charge an extra fee for its travel. An electronic US dollar in this car analogy would need permission to travel on roads built and owned by third parties who determines the rules and may charge fees along the way, or simply stop unwanted “cars” from reaching there destination for whatever reason.
The invention of Bitcoin
Bitcoin is the world’s first decentralized electronic currency. In November 2008, an article was published with the title ”Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System” by the pseudonym ”Satoshi Nakamoto” to an email list for cryptography on metzdowd.com. The article describes how a peer-to-peer electronic cash system can be created that makes it possible to send money directly between two parties without intermediaries.
The anonymous creator (or creators) of Bitcoin was the first to find a solution to how double-spending can be avoided in a decentralized electronic payment network. This problem had until then made it impossible to create an electronic currency without a central trusted third party to verify that the digital coins are not copied and used multiple times.
A decentralized solution to double-spending
The solution consists of all transactions being publicly published to all participants (nodes) in the network and for all participants to agree on a common history of every transaction which is locked cryptographically in a chronological chain of transaction blocks (a blockchain) through a process called proof-of-work. Proof-of-work is used to ensure that the longest blockchain was created by the majority of the computing power in the network, and it is always the longest blockchain that is considered as the correct transaction history. Bitcoin uses proof-of-work to solve the computer science problem “Byzantine Generals’ Problem” which concerns how different participants in an insecure communication network can coordinate with each other in a safe manner.
Incentives for verifying transactions, i.e. to lock in transactions in the blockchain by spending computational power, is given by rewarding those who manage to compute a cryptographic solution to a transaction block with a predetermined number of newly created bitcoins, and additionally they receive all the transaction fees that the transactions in the block contains. This process of creating new bitcoins by performing calculations that verifies transactions is called mining, it has similarities with the way new gold is put in circulation. The difficulty of finding a cryptographic solution to a block of transactions is automatically adjusted so that it takes on average 10 minutes for all the computing power connected to the network to randomly find a solution.
How bitcoins come into existence
All bitcoins that exists has been created as reward for solving blocks in the blockchain. From the beginning the reward was 50 new bitcoin per block, but every four years the reward is halved. The rate of increase (inflation) of bitcoin is thus high in the beginning but halves every four years, and the total number of bitcoins will eventually level off at 21 million. Each bitcoin is divisible into 100 million pieces, where the smallest unit 0.00000001 bitcoin is called one Satoshi.
The registered transactions in the blockchain is secure against manipulation as long as a cooperating group of malevolent actors do not control more than 50% of the computational power of the entire network. To modify an existing block in the blockchain a malicious actor would have to redo the proof-of-work needed for that specific block and all subsequent blocks, and catch up to become the longest chain. To do this requires a large percentage of the total computing power of the network and the probability of being able to modify a previous block falls rapidly with the number of new blocks added after that block.
If a malicious actor manages to come over more computing power than all others together, he can choose between two possibilities. The first option is to steal back his payments (double spend) and have power to determine which transactions he will allow others to make. The other option is to follow the rules and look forward to being awarded more bitcoins than everyone else combined in the future rather than undermining the credibility of the entire network and the basis of his own wealth.
Transparency and anonymity
In Bitcoin all transactions are public in a similar way as in a stock market. Everyone can see which transactions take place, there size and time, but they can be anonymous as long as no personal identities are associated with the individual account addresses used. However, in practice it is much more difficult to make anonymous transactions with bitcoin than with cash.
The price of bitcoin
The price of Bitcoin is determined solely by supply and demand in what constitutes one of the world’s most free global markets. When Bitcoin was first started in early 2009, bitcoins had no market value. One of the first known transactions that prescribed a value to bitcoin was initiated on the forum bitcointalk.org in May 2010 when the forum member Laszlo from Florida offered to pay 10,000 bitcoins for two pizzas.
The principle of how the price of bitcoins has increased since then is described by Ludwig von Mises’ regression theorem. This Theorem explains how something can go from being subjectively valued to something that obtains a more objective exchange value, such as money.
Features of good money
For something to be considered as money it needs to function as a medium of exchange, a measure of value and a way to store value. To be able to this as well as possible there are nine characteristics that determine what is good money. Those are: limited quantity, durability, portability, divisibility, ease of recognition, ease of storage, fungibility, difficulty to forge, and widespread use.
Keynesian vs Austrian school
The currency bitcoin can be thought of as price deflationary, i.e., the value of the currency will increase over time if bitcoin becomes a generally accepted currency, as the total number of bitcoins will never exceed 21 million. This means that prices of goods and services will fall in terms of bitcoins if the productivity of the economy continues to increase as more goods and services will chase the same amount of bitcoins.
Keynesian economists argue that price deflation is bad for primarily three reasons. First, it provides an incentive to save rather than to consume, and it reduces the incentive to borrow money. second, the real debt burden of borrowers will increase over time, and third, they argue that nominal wage cuts would be difficult to implement. According to Keynesian economics, it is desirable to push down lending rates and expand the money supply to provide incentives for increased borrowing and increased consumption in order to increase the economic activity to create more jobs.
Austrian economists argue on the contrary that the expansion of the total money supply (inflation) and depression of interest rates to artificially low levels is negative for the economy as a whole and the main cause of the business cycle. This is because the artificially depressed interest rates do not reflect the time preference of society, i.e. how much people are willing to postpone consumption in the present, in anticipation of a larger reward later. The artificially low interest rates means that investments can be made, that in a normal situation would not be profitable, because they are not sufficiently demanded by consumers. The aggregated undesired investments made possible through artificially low interest rates shows up sooner or later through a recession where businesses without sufficient demand for their products goes bankrupt resulting in high unemployment. In recessions Keynesian economists usually demands stimulus through the creation of even more money, even lower interest rates and more government spending, resulting in a temporary boom in which a new round of undesired investment are made because of artificially low interest rates and a large supply of new money and credit, and so it continues with booms and busts caused by centrally controlled manipulation of interest rates and money supply.
With a currency that increases in value over time as the economy grows people would probably not spend money on unnecessary consumption and be more thoughtful how they spend their money. This does not mean that they will stop consuming. If that were the case no computers or mobile phones would be sold since they are subject to rapid price deflation, constantly getting better and decreasing in price.
In an economy without expansion of the money supply and manipulation of interest rates, the interest rates would be determined by the amount of savings in the economy, reflecting the time preference of society. A currency that increases in value over time provides incentives for saving, which probably would give rise to a large amount of saved money and this would naturally drive down interest rates.
In an economy with price deflation an employer would not need to raise wages to compensate for increasing prices, but in real terms the salary would go up even if it was standing still nominally. If the rest of the economy is much more productive than a individual company, the value of the currency would rise faster than the profit of the individual company. This means that the product or service that the company produces is not demanded by society at the price they are capable of producing it. It is a signal from society that it would be better if they devoted their energy to produce something else that is more in demand. There are also historical examples where wages have fallen over 50% in nominal terms due to contraction of the total money supply in society (real deflation).
The biggest reason however why Keynesian economists want to make people terrified of deflation is probably because we live in a debt-based economy. In the economy we live in today about 97% of all circulating money is only credit, created by commercial banks on people’s bank accounts. This is clearly stated openly in this press release on money creation from Bank of England. This means that if a large proportion of bank customers would withdraw their money at the same time, the banks wouldn’t have coverage for it. This would lead to a chain reaction of banks going bankrupt and a large amount of money represented on people’s bank accounts would disappear from circulation. This would lead to a real deflation where the total amount of money decreases, in contrast to a price deflation where only the price decreases and not the total amount of money.
If bitcoin would become a dominant currency, centrally controlled manipulation of the economy through regulating money supply and interest rates would no longer be possible. In addition, bitcoin is not created through somebodies debt.
Another important aspect of Bitcoin is that transactions are irreversible. This reduces transaction costs and demands for identifications. In traditional payment networks, payments are reversible, which means that banks can not escape handling disputes. This in turn makes transaction costs higher and small transactions disproportionately expensive. Reversible transactions puts merchants in danger of being cheated, and for this reason they will insist on more information about their customers than they would otherwise need to protect themselves.
Because bitcoin transactions can not be reversed it is possible to safely receive payments from anonymous persons and persons you do not trust. This has always been possible with physical cash, but over electronic channels, this has not been possible before Bitcoin.
Bitcoin is open source
Another important aspect is that Bitcoin is completely open source software. Anyone with sufficient programming skills can check, copy, and if they want to start their own version of Bitcoin. There are thousands of different crypto-currencies created this way but Bitcoin is by far the dominant in terms of market value, GitHub repositories, venture capital investment, merchant adoption, and many other metrics.
Bitcoin is speech
Bitcoin is a protocol – a language that computers use to communicate with each other over the internet. In the same way that computers use the SMTP protocol to send email on the Internet and TCP / IP is one of the main protocols for creating the Internet.
Other uses of Bitcoin and blockchain technology
In this introductory text to Bitcoin, I have omitted other applications of the blockchain technology than for use as currency. The blockchain is a technology for recording ownership and trust in a decentralized way. There is much more that can be decentralized using this technology. To quote Andreas AntonopoIous ”Saying that Bitcoin is a currency is like saying that the internet is email. Currency is just the first app!”. All services currently performed via a central party can be and most likely will be decentralized and provided for lower cost in the future based on blockchain technology, e.g. trading, stocks, bonds, contracts, notary services, insurance, matchmaking services, law, dispute resolution, communication, crowdfunding, and much more.
Decentralization means that the power is distributed and this reduces the possibility of corruption.
Will bitcoin or some other decentralized cryptocurrency become a dominant global currency in the future? Only time will tell!